Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023: A Modern Penal Code
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) replaces the old Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), aiming to update India’s criminal laws. The IPC, created during British rule, had become outdated despite some updates. The BNS addresses modern issues like cybercrime and terrorism, and focuses on protecting women, children, and the nation.
Why Replace the IPC?
The IPC was too old for today’s problems. It was a colonial-era law, had confusing language, and didn’t focus enough on victims. The BNS is meant to fix these issues.
Key Changes:
- The penalty for group identity based murder is less than individual murder which is controversial.
- The removal of section 377 removes male rape and bestiality from the code.
- Community service is now a punishment option.
- “Sedition” is gone, replaced with laws against acts that threaten India’s unity.
- The BNS changes how mental illness is handled in criminal cases
- The definition of “terrorism” might be too broad.
- Some offenses overlap with other laws, causing potential confusion.
- “Terrorism” and “organized crime” are clearly defined.
- Group murders based on identity can get severe penalties.
- The age for criminal responsibility stays low, which is debated.
Key Features of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023 brings several significant updates aimed at addressing emerging legal challenges such as cybercrime, organized crime, and evolving societal concerns. The new provisions intensify punitive measures for serious offenses while also focusing on stronger human rights protections. Key changes include harsher penalties for the torture of public servants. The BNS retains much of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) related to offenses against the body, such as murder, suicide abetment, and grievous harm, while also introducing provisions targeting organized crime, terrorism, and group-driven violence based on identity factors. A notable change in sexual offenses is the raising of the minimum age for victims in gang-rape cases from 16 to 18, alongside penalties for sexual intercourse obtained through fraudulent promises. The BNS also removes sedition as an offense, instead criminalizing actions that threaten India’s sovereignty or unity through various means, including digital and financial transactions. Terrorism is broadly defined, with severe punishments for acts undermining national unity or causing harm. Organized crime is comprehensively addressed with penalties such as life imprisonment or death for crimes like kidnapping, extortion, and cybercrime. The law also introduces provisions to punish mob lynching, with sentences ranging from seven years to life imprisonment or death. Finally, the BNS aligns itself with key Supreme Court rulings, such as the decriminalization of adultery, and offers life imprisonment as an alternative to the death penalty for severe offenses committed by individuals already serving life sentences.
Structure of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023 is a progressive overhaul of India’s criminal justice system, bringing about several modernizations and changes compared to the old Indian Penal Code (IPC). Let’s take a closer look at the key features and provisions:
- Recognition of Transgender Rights
A significant step forward, the BNS explicitly acknowledges “transgender” as a distinct gender identity, standing alongside men and women. This recognition aligns with the landmark Supreme Court judgment in the NALSA vs. Union of India case, marking a crucial development in the protection of transgender rights. - Codified Substantive Law
The BNS serves as a thoroughly codified body of criminal law, replacing the long-standing IPC. It lays down a clear framework for various offenses and corresponding punishments, providing an organized structure to address criminal acts. Notably, it includes provisions for fines and victim rights, ensuring a more comprehensive approach to justice. - Digital Documentation Expansion
The BNS brings the legal framework into the digital age by updating the definition of ‘documents’ to encompass both electronic and digital records. This marks a significant adaptation to the increasing role of technology in modern-day legal proceedings. - Clarity in Definitions
One of the standout features of the BNS is its focus on providing precise definitions. Section 2 clarifies various terms used throughout the Sanhita, making it easier for the public and legal professionals to understand the provisions. - Crimes Against Women and Children
In a bid to address vulnerable groups, Chapter 5 of the BNS specifically categorizes crimes committed against women and children. While some critics have questioned the decision to group these offenses together, it serves to highlight the shared vulnerability of these groups to gender- and age-based crimes. - Emphasis on Reformative Justice
Reflecting a shift towards more rehabilitative measures, the BNS introduces a reformative justice approach. The focus is on rehabilitation, with provisions like community service introduced as a form of punishment for lesser offenses, marking a departure from purely punitive measures. - Global Reach of Indian Law
Under Section 48, the BNS extends its jurisdiction to cover offenses committed outside India but abetted by individuals acting within foreign jurisdictions. This ensures that Indian law can address crimes impacting the country, no matter where they occur globally. - Age of Consent Clarified
The BNS sets the age of consent for marriage at 18, in alignment with the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012, ensuring a uniform standard for adulthood and sexual consent. - False Promise to Marry Criminalized (Section 69)
The BNS makes it illegal to engage in sexual intercourse based on a false promise of marriage. This legal provision closes a loophole that previously allowed deceit to be used as a means of gaining consent. - Gender-Neutral Terms
The BNS takes a progressive stance by using gender-neutral terms like “whoever” in various sections. This change eliminates gender biases, especially in cases related to assault and voyeurism. - Medical Negligence Addressed (Section 106)
Medical negligence, which was previously an area of ambiguity, is now specifically addressed in the BNS. The law prescribes up to two years of imprisonment and fines, though it provides a more lenient approach than general criminal negligence laws. - Snatching Penalized (Section 304)
In response to the growing problem of snatching in urban areas, the BNS specifically criminalizes the act. Offenders can face up to three years in prison along with fines, making it a serious offense with corresponding consequences. - A New Approach to Sedition
a major reform under the BNS is the removal of the sedition law (formerly Section 124A of the IPC). However, Section 152 introduces new provisions that penalize acts threatening India’s sovereignty and unity, such as subversive or separatist activities, thus reflecting modern concerns regarding national security.
A Glimpse at Key Definitions in the BNS 2023
The BNS also updates several legal definitions that were either inconsistent with the IPC or were entirely absent. Here’s a breakdown:
- “Act”
In the BNS, the definition of “act” is treated separately, whereas the IPC combines “act” and “omission” under a single section. This separation allows for clearer interpretation of criminal actions. - “Child”
The BNS explicitly defines a child as anyone under the age of 18, ensuring a consistent standard of protection. The IPC did not have such a direct definition, making this a critical improvement in the new law. - “Gender”
In an inclusive step, the BNS recognizes “transgender” as a valid gender identity alongside “male” and “female,” a progressive shift compared to the IPC, which only acknowledged the latter two. - “Document”
The BNS expands the definition of “document” to include digital and electronic records, aligning the legal framework with technological advancements that are now integral to the digital world. - “Omission”
Unlike the IPC, which grouped both “act” and “omission” together, the BNS separates them, ensuring more precise definitions and applications of these terms in criminal cases.
Challenges in the Implementation of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023
(a).Change from “Unsound Mind” to “Mental Illness”
- Under the IPC, individuals with an unsound mind were exempt from prosecution. The BNS replaces this with “mental illness,” as defined in the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.
- This change excludes conditions like mental retardation, which may prevent certain individuals from being exempted. It also includes substance abuse as a potential defence for offenders claiming voluntary intoxication, differing from the IPC’s previous defence provisions.
- The Standing Committee on Home Affairs has recommended reverting to the term “unsound mind” for clarity.
(b).Broader Definition of Terrorism
- The BNS broadens the scope of terrorism to include acts aimed at disrupting public order, ranging from large-scale insurgencies to local disturbances.
- Terms like “intimidation” are vague, raising concerns. The Standing Committee has suggested refining these terms to avoid misinterpretation.
(c)Petty Offenses
- The BNS introduces provisions for petty organized crimes such as vehicle theft, pickpocketing, and gang-related exam paper sales.
- Terms like “gang,” “anchor points,” and “mobile organized crime groups” are inadequately defined, creating vagueness in interpretation.
- The vague requirement for creating “general feelings of insecurity” has led the Standing Committee to call for more precise language.
(d)Issues with Offenses against Minors
- The BNS sets age-specific guidelines for offenses, offering better protection for minors.
- However, the law differentiates between victims based on age in cases like rape and gang-rape, which leads to inconsistencies. The Protection of Children from Sexual Offenses Act, 2012, treats anyone under 18 as a minor.
- The Standing Committee has recommended standardizing the definition of a minor as anyone under 18.
(e)Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility
- The BNS keeps the IPC’s minimum age for criminal responsibility at seven, with an option to increase it to 12 depending on the child’s understanding.
- This is lower than in many countries, such as Germany (14), Scotland (14), and England and Wales (10).
(f)Duplication of Offenses and Legal Overlap
- The IPC was initially intended to cover all criminal offenses. New laws, such as those on weights and measures, are now governed by the Legal Metrology Act, 2009.
- However, the BNS overlaps with several existing special laws related to organized crime and terrorism, creating potential duplication, compliance challenges, and inconsistent penalties across different legal frameworks.
(g)Handling Crimes Related to Organized Crime and Terrorism
- Organized crime and terrorism were not explicitly addressed by the IPC. These crimes are handled by laws like the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA) and state laws such as MCOCA.
- The BNS aims to address gaps in states without specific laws, but this could lead to duplication in states already equipped with relevant legislation.
(h)Offenses Concerning Women
- While the BNS retains many provisions from the IPC regarding offenses like rape, it does not fully implement the recommendations from the Justice Verma Committee (2013) or the Supreme Court’s suggestions for reforming laws to enhance women’s safety.
(i)Changes in Sedition Provisions
- Sedition in the IPC pertains to acts that incite hatred or contempt against the government. Although sedition charges are suspended, the BNS replaces this offense with provisions criminalizing:
- Inciting secession, armed rebellion, or subversive actions.
- Promoting separatist sentiments.
- Endangering India’s sovereignty, unity, or integrity.
- These actions could be conducted through various means, including verbal communication, written words, digital media, or financial transactions.
- Critics argue that these provisions still retain elements of sedition and expand the scope of activities that threaten national unity, with concerns over the vague term “subversive activities.”
(j)The Issue of Solitary Confinement
- The IPC permits solitary confinement for severe offenses such as criminal conspiracy, sexual harassment, and kidnapping. The BNS retains this provision.
- However, solitary confinement is increasingly seen as a violation of human rights. The Supreme Court’s 1979 ruling held that solitary confinement violates Article 21, and the Law Commission had recommended its abolition.
- Despite this, the BNS allows solitary confinement only in exceptional circumstances.
(k)Uncertainty Regarding Community Service
- The BNS introduces community service as a form of punishment for minor offenses like petty theft, obstructing a public servant, and public intoxication.
- However, the law does not define the scope or implementation of community service clearly, creating practical challenges and uncertainty regarding its application.
BNS 2023: Good Ideas, Mixed Results
The BNS 2023 tries to modernize India’s criminal law, especially for transgender rights and crimes against women and children. It also adds community service as a punishment.
However, the BNS shows a lack of consistent thinking. For example, it strengthens laws against sexual abuse, but still doesn’t recognize marital rape or make rape laws gender-neutral, which seems contradictory.
Another issue is how punishments are decided. The BNS increases penalties but doesn’t clearly say if it’s meant to deter crime, rehabilitate offenders, or just punish. This lack of direction could lead to unfair punishments. Community service is a good idea, but it’s only used for a few minor crimes.
In short:
The BNS 2023 has positive changes, but it needs a clearer, more consistent approach. It should focus more on helping offenders change and supporting victims, and aim for a fairer justice system.
Disclaimer: The content in this article is for informational purposes only. KanoonKiBaat does not intend to defame, harm, or cause damages to any individual, organization, or entity. KanoonKiBaat is not responsible for any claims, damages, or legal actions arising from the use of this information. KanoonKiBaat will not be held liable for any consequences resulting from the use of this content.
Always seek professional legal advice before making any decisions based on this information.
